Files
yellowjacket/.planning/audits/2026-08-11-ui/perf.md
T
logan 9e92721bb7
Build & publish Arch package / arch-package (push) Successful in 1m58s
CI / check (push) Successful in 2m47s
Search index maintenance / maintain-index (push) Successful in 7s
CI / e2e (push) Failing after 2m52s
docs: record plan 007, its four audits, and what measuring corrected
`.planning/audits/2026-08-11-ui/` is the pass this work came from: the
app driven by hand headless plus three static reviews, ~118 findings
that are really five problems, each spread by being copied rather than
fixed. `.planning/plans/active/007-ui-reconciliation.md` sequences them
by blast radius and records what each of the six passes actually
shipped — including twenty-five entries under "where the plan was
wrong", which is the point of writing it down.

The discipline those entries add up to, now in NOTES.md: a finding is
three hypotheses — how big it is, why it is that big, and what to do
about it — and they can be independently right and wrong. Three of the
audit's recommended fixes would have shipped a bug (`m1` stops the
card grids repainting, `m6`'s index-ordered selection goes stale on
any re-sort, `m5`'s guard leaves the marquee short), all three because
they reasoned from the shape of the code and not from what the rest of
the file already knew about it. Five findings evaporated or inverted
on contact.

CLAUDE.md gains the invariants that came out of it, and the skill
gains the fourteen measurement traps, each of which produced a wrong
number first — the newest being that a longtask entry arrives after
the task that produced it, so two numbers that must agree are worth
more than one you have to be sceptical about.
2026-08-12 01:20:13 -04:00

506 lines
28 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Frontend performance / memory / state-correctness audit
**Scope:** `frontend/src/store/**`, `frontend/src/components/**`, `frontend/src/events.ts`,
`frontend/vite.config.mts`, `frontend/package.json`, `frontend/index.ts`, `frontend/index.html`.
Read-only. Nothing in the repo was modified. (Two throwaway production builds were emitted to
`/tmp/yjbuild*` to measure bundle composition; `frontend/dist/` was not touched.)
**Excluded as already-known** (traced for consequences, not re-reported): views never unmount,
`autotag-view`'s document keydown, `IndexStatusChanged` every 3 s, seek-bar drift.
---
## Critical
### C1 — Finishing a track re-downloads the entire library
`backend/queue/playhistory.go:63``frontend/src/store/library-store.ts:85``:445`
`recordPlay()` emits `TrackMetadataChanged` on **every naturally finished track**
(`backend/queue/handlers.go:24,34,45,52`). `LibraryStore` treats that event exactly like a retag:
`invalidate()` nulls tracks/albums/artists/genres and immediately `eagerFetch()`es all four
(`library-store.ts:445-476`). On a 50 k-track library that is `GetAllTracks` +
`GetAllAlbums` + `GetAllArtists` + `GetAllGenresWithCounts` — roughly 25 MB of JSON across the
Wails IPC, parsed on the main thread — **once per song**, forever, whether or not the user is
looking at a list.
The invalidation itself is correct and deliberate (`frontend/test/stores/library-store.test.ts:94-110`
asserts it); the defect is that the backend reuses one event for "tags were rewritten" and
"play_count went up by one".
*Symptom:* a multi-second main-thread stall between every two tracks on a large library, plus
constant SQLite churn.
*Fix:* emit a distinct `TrackPlayCountChanged` from `recordPlay` and have `LibraryStore` patch the
one track in place instead of invalidating.
### C2 — …and silently wipes the user's selection while it does
`frontend/src/components/track-list/track-list.ts:1198-1211``:1242-1246`
`updated()` notices `libraryCtrl.cachedTracks` has a new identity and calls `loadTracks()`, which
does `this.selection.clear()` (`:1246`). Combined with C1, **every track change clears whatever the
user had selected in the track list.** Selecting 40 tracks to drag into a playlist while music plays
is not possible.
*Fix:* re-key the selection against the new array (`selection` is keyed by `FilePath`, which
survives a refetch) instead of clearing it.
### C3 — Library-filter / rescan race caches the wrong library's data
`frontend/src/store/library-store.ts:133-155` (and the identical `getAlbums`/`getArtists`/`getGenres`)
`getTracks()` guards on `tracksLoading`, but `invalidate()` (`:445`) clears `tracks` **without**
clearing `tracksLoading`. Sequence:
1. `getTracks()` starts for library A → `tracksLoading = true`.
2. User picks library B → `setSelectedLibrary` (`:339`) → `invalidate()``tracks = null`,
`eagerFetch()``getTracks()` sees `tracks === null && tracksLoading === true` → returns
`waitForTracks()`.
3. Library A's response lands, is stored as `this.tracks`, `changeGen++`.
4. `waitForTracks()` resolves with library A's tracks — under library B's filter.
The same window exists for `LibraryScanComplete` arriving while a fetch is in flight, in which case
the pre-scan snapshot is cached as if it were post-scan and the newly scanned tracks never appear.
*Fix:* stamp each fetch with a request id (or the `selectedLibraryIdValue` + `changeGen` it started
under) and discard the result if it no longer matches.
### C4 — `waitFor*` never resolves on a failed fetch, and leaks a subscriber forever
`frontend/src/store/library-store.ts:494-547` (4 copies), `frontend/src/store/playlist-store.ts:143-157`
`waitForTracks()` resolves only when `!tracksLoading && tracks !== null`. If the underlying binding
rejects, `finally` sets `tracksLoading = false` but `tracks` stays `null`, so the promise **never
settles** and its `subscribe()` callback is never removed from `LibraryStore.subscribers`. Every
component or `explore-link` lookup awaiting that promise hangs, and each hung wait permanently adds
a closure to the notify set that runs on every subsequent store change. `eagerFetch()`'s
`void this.getTracks()` (`:474-477`) also swallows the rejection into an unhandled promise rejection.
*Fix:* have the fetch record an error state and reject/resolve all waiters in `finally`.
### C5 — Adding one track to one playlist re-downloads every track of every playlist
`frontend/src/store/playlist-store.ts:31-33``:124-129``:60`
`PlaylistTracksChanged` (emitted from 8 backend sites including `backend/playlist/favorites.go:200,231`)
calls `invalidate()``GetAllPlaylistsWithTracks()`, which the backend implements as
`GetAllPlaylists` + `GetAllPlaylistTracksWithMetadata` — **all rows of all playlists with full track
metadata** (`backend/playlist/playlist.go:206-234`).
Toggling a single heart in the track list therefore refetches every playlist in the app. The store
does this unconditionally (`void this.getPlaylists()` inside `invalidate()`), so it fires even when
`playlist-view` — the only subscriber — has never been opened.
*Fix:* the event already carries the playlist id; refetch that one playlist, and only when there is
a subscriber.
---
## Major
### M1 — One keystroke in the search box re-ranks every list in the app
`frontend/src/store/search-store.ts:55-57`, `frontend/src/store/controllers/search-controller.ts:29-32`
`SearchStore.notify()` is an unbatched broadcast to every subscriber, and `SearchController` maps it
straight to `host.requestUpdate()`. Eight components hold a `SearchController`
(`track-list`, `cover-grid`, `artists-view`, `genres-view`, `playlist-view`, `playlist-details`,
`smart-playlist-details`, `search-bar`) and — because views stay mounted — **all of the mounted ones
recompute on every keystroke**, not just the visible one:
- `track-list``rankTracks()` over 50 k tracks (`track-list.ts:271-289`)
- `cover-grid` → filter + `[...albums].sort()` over 5 k albums (`cover-grid.ts:215-248`)
- `artists-view`, `genres-view` → their own filter passes
Measured on Node/V8 (WebKit2GTK will be slower): `rankTracks`-equivalent work over 50 k tracks is
**~18 ms**, so a single keystroke costs 50100 ms of main-thread work across the mounted set even
though four of the five results are invisible.
*Fix:* gate the notify on `searchStore.isSearchableView()` matching the subscriber's own view (the
predicate already exists at `search-store.ts:41-43`), or have `SearchController` skip
`requestUpdate()` when its host carries `view-hidden`.
### M2 — `rankTracks` allocates a `Set` and a closure per track, per keystroke
`frontend/src/components/track-list/search-ranking.ts:98-135`
`scoreTrack()` builds `new Set<string>()` plus a `check` closure for **every** track, then calls
`col.accessor(track).toLowerCase()` (a fresh string allocation) per field. At 50 k tracks × 3 core
fields that is 50 k Sets, 50 k closures and 150 k throwaway strings per keystroke. Benchmarked
against a flat three-field comparison: **18.1 ms vs 5.8 ms** — a 3× tax purely from the dedup
machinery, for a `seen` set that only ever contains 36 fixed ids.
*Fix:* hoist the deduped column list out of the per-track loop (compute it once in `rankTracks`) and
drop the closure.
### M3 — Full-size original cover art rendered as a 24 px thumbnail in the track list
`frontend/src/components/track-list/columns.ts:53-63`
The `albumArt` column renders `track.CoverArtPath` — the **original embedded artwork**, commonly
1500×1500 and several hundred KB — scaled to `width:24px;height:24px` by CSS. `CoverArtSmall`
(100 px, quality 75) and `CoverArtMedium` (200 px) already exist on the same model
(`wailsjs/go/models.ts:1583-1586`, generated by `backend/library/coverart.go:41-45`) and are used
correctly everywhere else. There is also no `loading="lazy"` and no `decoding="async"`, so every row
the virtualizer scrolls into view decodes a full-resolution JPEG synchronously on the main thread.
*Symptom:* enabling the Art column makes track-list scrolling stutter and inflates memory by the
decoded bitmap of every album scrolled past.
*Fix:* `track.CoverArtSmall || track.CoverArtPath`, plus `loading="lazy" decoding="async"`.
### M4 — Artist grid does a full linear scan of the album cache per card, per frame
`frontend/src/components/artists-view/artists-view.ts:988-1029`, called from `:1044` /
`.renderItem` at `:1298`
When an artist has no `ImageSmall/Medium/Large` — the common case for a locally-tagged library —
`renderArtistAvatar()` falls back to scanning **all of `libraryStore.cachedAlbums`** with
`a.ArtistName.toLowerCase() === name` until it finds a match, allocating two lowercased strings per
comparison. This runs inside the virtualizer's `renderItem`, i.e. for every visible card on every
render pass. At 5 000 albums × ~50 visible cards that is 250 000 comparisons and 500 000 string
allocations per scroll frame.
*Fix:* build a `Map<lowercasedArtistName, coverUrls>` once when `cachedAlbums` identity changes, and
look up in O(1).
### M5 — Playlist and smart-playlist track lists are not virtualized
`frontend/src/components/playlist-details/playlist-details.ts:1265-1396`,
`frontend/src/components/smart-playlist-details/smart-playlist-details.ts:1176-1250`
Both render **every** track with a plain `.map()` — no `lit-virtualizer`, no `repeat()` key. For a
2 000-track playlist that is 2 000 rows × 8 elements in the DOM, and:
- `getVisibleTracks()` (`playlist-details.ts:750-780`) allocates a fresh `{track, trackIndex}`
wrapper object for every track on **every** render, so the array identity always changes;
- five event bindings per row (`@click`, `@dblclick`, `@contextmenu`, `@dragstart`, `@dragend`,
`:1305-1330`) are new arrow functions each render, so lit removes and re-adds 10 000 listeners
per pass;
- both components hold a `PlayerController` (`playlist-details.ts` imports it), whose subscription
is unfiltered — so **every** `PlaybackStateChanged` / `TrackChanged` / `VolumeChanged` /
`MuteChanged` triggers that whole pass;
- the row `<img>` (`:1386`, `smart-playlist-details.ts:1245`) has no `loading="lazy"`, so opening a
2 000-track playlist fires 2 000 simultaneous cover-art requests at the Go asset handler.
Both files are ~30 kB of the bundle each and duplicate the same list; `track-list` already solves
all of this (delegated handlers via `data-index`, stable `renderItem`, memoized caches) and is
already reused by `genre-details.ts:276-278` via `.externalTracks`.
*Fix:* render these with `<track-list .externalTracks=…>` the way `genre-details` does, or at minimum
add `lit-virtualizer` + delegated handlers.
### M6 — Visiting Settings costs a full re-render (and a console entry) every 3 seconds, forever
`frontend/src/components/config-page/config-page.ts:1016-1022`, `@state` at `:186`
The `IndexStatusChanged` handler assigns a freshly deserialized object to a `@state` field, so the
identity always differs and Lit re-renders the entire 2 149-line `config-page` template every 3 s —
for the rest of the session, since `config-page` is a cached primary view that never unmounts
(`index.ts:71`) and its `disconnectedCallback` cleanup (`:1024-1036`, including
`this.cancelIndexStatus?.()`) never runs.
The handler also does `console.log('IndexStatusChanged event received', status)` on every tick. With
devtools open that retains ~1 200 status objects per hour as a genuine, unbounded leak.
*Fix:* drop the `console.log`; compare the incoming status field-wise and only assign on change.
### M7 — `explore-view` retains base64 image data forever
`frontend/src/components/explore-view/explore-view.ts:99-100`, `:987`, `:1003-1019`, `:936-944`
`thumbnailCache` stores the **data URL** returned by `GetThumbnails`
`"data:image/jpeg;base64," + base64(front-250 JPEG)` (`backend/explore/coverartproxy.go:114`,
`backend/explore/coverart.go:27-29`). A 250 px CAA JPEG is ~1525 kB, ~2033 kB base64, and JS
strings are UTF-16, so **~4066 kB of retained heap per cached album**, plus the browser's decoded
bitmap keyed off that same multi-kilobyte string.
Neither `thumbnailCache` nor `artistImageCache` is ever evicted, and `explore-view` is a cached
primary view (`index.ts:67`) that never unmounts. A session of browsing — a desktop player runs for
days — grows monotonically: a few hundred searches × ~50 results is on the order of hundreds of MB.
*Fix:* cap both maps with an LRU (a few hundred entries), or return a `/coverart/<mbid>` URL from the
backend instead of a data URL so the browser's own image cache handles eviction.
### M8 — `exploreCache` is a second unbounded, never-evicted cache
`frontend/src/store/explore-cache.ts:35-38`
Four module-level `Map`s (`artists`, `albums`, `artistAlbums`, `artistTopTracks`) with `set` but no
`delete`, no size cap and no TTL. `artistAlbums` holds full `MBReleaseGroup[]` discographies and
`artistTopTracks` full `LBTopRecording[]` lists. Grows for the lifetime of the process.
*Fix:* bound each map (LRU, ~100 entries is plenty for "avoid a refetch when the user hits back").
### M9 — Every `<wa-icon>` is fetched from a remote CDN at runtime
`frontend/index.ts:29-30,47`; resolver in
`@awesome.me/webawesome/dist/chunks/chunk.F5JLNOSF.js` (`library.default`)
WebAwesome's default icon library resolves to
`https://ka-f.fontawesome.com/releases/v7.1.0/svgs/<folder>/<name>.svg`. The literal is present in
the built bundle. `setBasePath('/dist/webawesome')` does **not** change this — `getBasePath` is only
consumed by the component autoloader (`chunk.2PWIIYRH.js:51`), and no
`registerIconLibrary(...)` call exists anywhere in the app.
There are 165 `<wa-icon>` instances across 36 distinct names, so first paint of each view fires up to
36 cross-origin requests. The icon module caches by URL, so it is bounded per session — but a
desktop music player that is offline, on a captive network, or behind a firewall renders **no icons
at all**, and cold start waits on fontawesome.com.
*Fix:* register a local icon library resolving to bundled SVGs (`src/assets/images/icons/` already
holds a set), and add a `vite-plugin-static-copy` rule — the plugin is already a declared devDep
(`package.json`) but is not referenced by `vite.config.mts`, and `dist/webawesome/` does not exist.
### M10 — 1.18 MB single chunk, no route-level code splitting
`frontend/vite.config.mts:16-22`, `frontend/index.ts:1-27`
Verified build (`vite build --outDir /tmp/yjbuild`):
```
assets/main-BAFmIgXb.css 53.46 kB │ gzip: 7.48 kB
assets/main-yB2fsiPY.js 1,183.64 kB │ gzip: 242.14 kB
(!) Some chunks are larger than 500 kB after minification.
```
`rollupOptions` sets only `input`; there is no `manualChunks` and no `import()` anywhere, and
`index.ts` statically imports all 27 views, so every module is downloaded, parsed and
**side-effect-evaluated** (every store singleton constructed, every `@customElement` registered)
before first paint.
Sourcemap-attributed composition of the 1.16 MB of mapped output:
| bytes | source |
|---|---|
| 199 497 | `@awesome.me/webawesome` |
| 76 008 | `components/autotag-view/autotag-view.ts` |
| 52 828 | `components/explore-artist-details/…` |
| 48 519 | `components/config-page/config-page.ts` |
| 42 172 | `components/track-details/track-details.ts` |
| 37 394 | `@lit-labs/virtualizer` |
| 36 666 | `components/playlist-view/playlist-view.ts` |
| 36 333 | `components/explore-album-details/…` |
| 34 457 | `components/explore-view/explore-view.ts` |
| 31 317 | `components/track-list/track-list.ts` |
| 30 989 | `components/playlist-details/…` |
| 30 661 | `components/cover-grid/cover-grid.ts` |
| 30 180 | `wailsjs/go/models.ts` |
The startup-critical path is roughly `track-list` + `cover-grid` + `now-playing` + `audio-player` +
`app-sidebar` + lit + virtualizer ≈ 200 kB. `autotag-view` (76 kB, the single largest app module),
`config-page`, `explore-*`, `track-details`, `jobs-*` and `downloads-view` are all reachable only
from a sidebar click.
*Fix:* replace the static imports in `index.ts` with `await import()` inside the `navigate` handler's
`VIEW_TAGS` branch — the view is already created lazily there (`index.ts:120-127`), only the module
is eager.
---
## Minor
### m1 — `.renderItem` / `.keyFunction` are new closures every render in two virtualized views
`frontend/src/components/artists-view/artists-view.ts:1298-1299`,
`frontend/src/components/genres-view/genres-view.ts:1196-1197`
`LitVirtualizer` declares both as `@property()` with the default `!==` `hasChanged`
(`@lit-labs/virtualizer/LitVirtualizer.js:48-54`), so a fresh arrow function marks the property
dirty and forces the virtualizer's own render pass on every host update. `cover-grid.ts:1893-1894`
and `track-list.ts:1936-1937` correctly bind the stable `this.renderGridEntry` /
`this.renderTrackRow` — these two do not. (`keyFunction` is a fresh closure in all four; `repeat()`
keying limits the DOM damage to re-evaluated templates for the visible window.)
*Fix:* hoist to bound class fields, as `cover-grid` already does.
### m2 — Serial N+1 binding calls behind "play these"
- `frontend/src/components/artists-view/artists-view.ts:945-971``GetAlbumsByArtist`, then
`await GetAlbumTracks(album.ID)` **inside a `for` loop**. A 30-album artist is 31 sequential IPC
round-trips.
- `frontend/src/components/cover-grid/album-selection.ts:100-112` — same shape; Ctrl+A over 5 000
albums is 5 000 sequential round-trips (partly mitigated by `albumFilePathCache`).
- `frontend/src/components/genres-view/genres-view.ts:740-751` — one `GetTracksByGenre` per selected
genre, all fired concurrently, each returning full track rows that are then deduped client-side.
*Fix:* add a single `GetTracksByAlbumIDs([]int64)` / `GetTracksByGenres([]string)` binding.
### m3 — Timers that survive because their view never unmounts
The cleanup is written correctly; it simply never executes for cached primary views.
- `frontend/src/components/downloads-view/downloads-view.ts:216-218` — a 30 s `setInterval` clock,
cleared at `:226` in `disconnectedCallback`. Once Downloads is visited it ticks and re-renders the
view for the rest of the session.
- `frontend/src/components/now-playing/now-playing.ts:481,503``onScrollCycleEnd` schedules
`startScrollCycle` (2 s) which schedules the scroll (1.5 s), indefinitely, so a long track title
drives a state change + re-render every ~3.5 s forever while it plays.
*Fix:* drive these off the `view-hidden` class (a `MutationObserver` on the host, or an explicit
`viewActivated`/`viewDeactivated` hook in `index.ts`) rather than connect/disconnect.
### m4 — Permanent global `mousemove`/`mouseup` listeners for drag interactions
`frontend/src/components/track-list/track-list.ts:1076-1077`,
`frontend/src/components/now-playing/now-playing.ts:240-241`
Column resize and panel resize register document-level `mousemove` in `connectedCallback` and only
remove it in `disconnectedCallback`. Both guard-and-return immediately
(`track-list.ts:622-623`, `now-playing.ts:582-583`), so the cost is small, but they run on every
pointer move anywhere in the app for the process lifetime and defeat the browser's ability to skip
the listener entirely.
*Fix:* attach on `mousedown`, detach on `mouseup` — the standard drag pattern.
### m5 — `updated()` does unconditional DOM work every cycle
- `frontend/src/components/artists-view/artists-view.ts:417-420` and
`genres-view.ts:409-412``updateSizeProperties()` writes 2 `style.setProperty` calls on the host
unconditionally (`artists-view.ts:671-701`), and `ensureWheelListener()` does a
`shadowRoot.querySelector` every pass just to check a boolean it already stores
(`:611-629`). Both should be guarded on the value/flag they already track.
- `frontend/src/components/now-playing/now-playing.ts:259-263``checkOverflows()` +
`applyScrollDistances()` do 6 `querySelector`s and interleave `scrollWidth`/`clientWidth` reads
with `style.setProperty` writes on every update, i.e. forced synchronous layout followed by
invalidation, on a component that re-renders on every player-store change.
### m6 — O(total items) helpers on the selection hot path
`frontend/src/utils/selection-controller.ts:160-173`
`getSelectedKeysOrdered()` walks the entire item list (50 k `getItemKey` calls) rather than the
selection. It is called from every context-menu action, every favourite toggle and every
`dragstart` (`track-list.ts:1379-1400`), so starting a drag of one row costs a 50 k-iteration loop.
Related: `frontend/src/components/track-list/track-list.ts:1507-1520`
`openBatchTrackDetails` does `filePaths.map(fp => this.tracks.find(...))`, i.e. O(selection × total).
"Select all → Edit tags" on 50 k tracks is 2.5 × 10⁹ comparisons and will hang the renderer.
*Fix:* keep an index-ordered selection, and build a `Map<FilePath, Track>` for the batch lookup.
### m7 — The queue list stays live at zero width
`frontend/src/components/queue-panel/queue-panel.ts:214-231` (`:host { width: 0 }` when closed),
`:653-681`
`contain: layout style paint` limits the blast radius, but the `lit-virtualizer` inside still has a
real height and `min-width: 300px`, so it renders and measures its visible window on every queue
change even with the panel closed — and `updated()` calls `scrollToIndex()` (`:675`) on every
current-index change, which is `element(i).scrollIntoView()` on a laid-out but invisible element.
*Fix:* render `nothing` for the list body when the `open` attribute is absent.
### m8 — Backend emits scan progress nothing listens to
`frontend/src/events.ts:34-35`
`LibraryScanStarted` and `LibraryScanProgress` are declared but have **zero** consumers in
`frontend/src/`. During a 50 k-file scan the backend serializes and pushes a progress payload across
the IPC for an empty listener set.
*Fix:* either wire them into a scan indicator or stop emitting them.
### m9 — Remote artist avatars in Explore load eagerly
`frontend/src/components/explore-view/explore-view.ts:1461-1465`
The artist avatar `<img>` has neither `loading="lazy"` nor `decoding="async"`, unlike the album card
20 lines below (`:1515-1519`) which has both. Every artist in a search result starts loading
immediately.
---
## Polish
### p1 — Dead dependency
`@lit-labs/signals` is declared in `frontend/package.json` but imported nowhere in `src/` or
`index.ts`. Rollup tree-shakes it out of the bundle, so this is install-size only — but it also
signals a state-management direction that was never taken, next to five hand-rolled
`Set<Subscriber>` stores.
### p2 — Dead code carried in the bundle
`frontend/src/components/cover-grid/cover-grid.ts:1908-1962``renderSplitGrid()` is documented in
its own comment as "Currently unreferenced (the single-grid path is the active rendering mode)",
along with `getBeforeEntries`/`getAfterEntries`/`ensureSplitCache` and the `splitMode` branches that
feed it. `cover-grid.ts` is 30.6 kB of the bundle.
### p3 — Store notify batching is inconsistent
`library-store`, `player-store`, `queue-store`, `job-store` and `download-store` all coalesce with
`queueMicrotask` + a `notifyScheduled` flag. `search-store.ts:55-57` and `playlist-store.ts:133-135`
do not. Lit batches the resulting `requestUpdate()`s anyway, so the impact is small, but the
inconsistency is the kind that hides a real double-notify later.
### p4 — Empty library reads as "Loading tracks..." forever
`frontend/src/components/track-list/track-list.ts:1900-1902` branches on `this.tracks.length === 0`
rather than a loading flag, so a genuinely empty (or fully filtered-out) library shows a permanent
loading message. `libraryCtrl.tracksLoading` already exists for this.
### p5 — `selectAll()` compares sizes, not membership
`frontend/src/utils/selection-controller.ts:148``if (next.size === this._selectedItems.size) return;`
short-circuits on cardinality alone. Same-size-different-membership is hard to reach today, but the
guard is wrong as written; comparing against `this.host.getItemCount()` would express the intent.
### p6 — `ResizeObserver` on hidden views writes localStorage on every navigation
`frontend/src/components/track-list/track-list.ts:1079-1085``onHostResize` (`:1218-1243`) →
`normalizeWidths` + `saveColumnWidths` (`:515-534`). `.view-hidden` is
`visibility: hidden; height: 0` (`frontend/index.css:162-170`), not `display: none`, so hidden views
stay in the layout tree and their `ResizeObserver`s fire on every navigation. Cheap (localStorage
only), but it is work done for an invisible element.
---
## What is already right
Worth stating plainly, because it is most of the codebase and the findings above are the exceptions:
- **`track-list` is a well-built virtualized list.** Memoized filter/sort caches keyed on input
identity (`:238-270`), delegated event handlers via `data-index` with zero per-row closures
(`:1140-1157`, `:1290-1312`), a stable `renderItem`, an `_itemSize` hint that avoids
lit-virtualizer's scroll-error correction (`:222-228`), RAF-throttled scroll persistence
(`:1280-1291`), and an inline `<svg>` for the per-row favourite icon instead of a `<wa-icon>` that
would fetch. All 50 k rows go through this path.
- **`cover-grid` memoizes correctly** — `buildGridEntries()` is keyed on the filtered-albums array
identity (`:906-926`), so the virtualizer's `items` reference is stable across re-renders, and its
covers pick the right thumbnail tier with `loading="lazy" decoding="async"` and explicit
`width`/`height` (`:1803-1814`).
- **`queue-store` is delta-driven**, not snapshot-driven (`queue-store.ts:82-110`) — index, mode and
track-list mutations each ride their own event.
- **`job-store` is the model for a push store**: microtask-coalesced notify with a documented
rationale, and it evicts cached logs for jobs the backend has forgotten
(`job-store.ts:229-236, 263-276`).
- **`favorites-store` is Set-keyed**, so `isFavorited` in a row render is O(1) (`:99-101`).
- **`LibraryController`'s `changeGeneration` guard** correctly suppresses `requestUpdate()` when only
a loading flag toggled (`library-controller.ts:33-47`) — exactly the granularity most of the other
controllers lack.
- **`genre-details` and `artist-details` reuse `track-list` / `cover-grid`** via `.externalTracks` /
`.externalAlbums` instead of reimplementing a list — which is precisely the fix M5 asks for.
- **Detail views are ephemeral** (`index.ts:143-147`), so their `disconnectedCallback` cleanup does
run and their per-instance caches (e.g. `explore-artist-details`' three `Map`s) are collectable.
The leaks in M7/M8/m3 are all on the *cached* primary views.
## Things I checked and found no problem with
Recorded so they are not re-audited:
- **`localeCompare` in sort comparators** (`track-list/columns.ts:15`,
`cover-grid/cover-grid-types.ts:50-76`). Benchmarked 50 k-element sorts: bare `localeCompare`
**16.5 ms** vs a hoisted `Intl.Collator.compare` **28.7 ms**. V8 already caches the default
collator; hoisting one would be a pessimization. No finding.
- **Repeated `addEventListener('visibilityChanged', this.onVisibilityChanged)` in
`track-list.loadTracks()`** (`:1249-1254`). The handler is a stable class-field arrow, so repeat
registration with the same type+function is a spec-level no-op. Not a leak.
- **WebAwesome's autoloader `MutationObserver`.** `startLoader()` is exported from
`webawesome.js` but never called by the app, so no global mutation observer is installed. (The
icon CDN issue in M9 is a separate mechanism.)
- **`layout shift` from row cover art.** Every list container has a fixed pixel box
(`playlist-details.ts:984-998`, `columns.ts:61`, `cover-grid.ts:1809-1810`), so images do not
reflow their rows.
- **`job-store` / `download-store` growth.** Both bound their state to the backend snapshot and
evict.