docs(shell): the phone has no top bar, and why the modal is a dialog
CI / check (push) Skipped
CI / e2e (push) Skipped
CI / check (pull_request) Successful in 2m29s
CI / e2e (pull_request) Successful in 8m19s

CLAUDE.md's shell prose said the phone's header "controls shrink or
stand down"; there is no header there now. The search box's section
gains the modal and the four rules behind it, page-header gains the
count as the last thing to yield, and the top-bar-fit section gains
what happens below its own band.

NOTES.md gets the three measured facts, dated: `contain: paint` is why
a Web Awesome popup is clipped on Chrome 113 and why no tier here can
reproduce it, the arithmetic that cost the page header its count at
320px, and the shared long-lived e2e app that makes an absolute
coordinate a hidden assertion about background jobs.
This commit is contained in:
2026-08-20 20:03:28 -04:00
parent 1ab767a317
commit d6f7412e9d
2 changed files with 187 additions and 11 deletions
+79
View File
@@ -4350,3 +4350,82 @@ The corollary for anything that draws over the shell: **run the whole
e2e suite, not the spec you wrote.** A spec written for a feature
asserts the feature works; what a new overlay breaks is everything
else, and only the suite is looking at that.
## `contain: paint` is why a Web Awesome popup is clipped on the device (read 2026-08-20, applied 2026-08-21)
Recorded here because it outlives #57 and #60 both, and because the
next person to reach for a floating surface will reach for `wa-popup`.
`wa-popup` renders `<div popover="manual">` and feature-detects the
Popover API, falling back to `strategy: "fixed"` where there is none.
The reference device is Chrome 113 and `popover` is Chrome 114, so
every popup in the app takes the fallback there. `position: fixed`
escapes ancestor *overflow* but not `contain: paint`, which makes an
element a containing block for fixed descendants **and clips them** —
and `index.css` puts `contain: layout style paint` on `.main-panel`
and on `div.sidebar`.
So the rule is: **a floating surface opened from inside the main panel
must be a `wa-dialog`, not a `wa-popup`,** because `<dialog>` /
`showModal()` is Chrome 37 and uses the real top layer. #57's search
modal is one on that ground alone; #60 is the same finding applied to
the six context menus.
The half that costs time is the second one. **No tier here can
reproduce the clip.** CI's Chromium and WebKit both have the Popover
API, so a popup is top-layered and correct, and a spec asserting "the
surface is not clipped" is green on the broken build. Assert the
*mechanism* — that there is a native `<dialog>` in the tree at phone
width — which is the one form of the question a browser here answers
honestly.
## Removing the phone's top bar cost the page header its count (measured 2026-08-21)
#57 deletes the `top-bar` grid row below 600px and puts a 40px search
button in `page-header` instead. That button is 43px more than the row
has at 320px, which is a width the app promises (WCAG 1.4.10 reflow,
and `header-action-overflow.spec.ts` asks about it).
Measured on Playlists at 320px, after the fit pass had already
collapsed all three actions into "More actions" and truncated the title
to nothing: title 0, count 50, sort 143, search 40, More 38, five 12px
gaps, 32px of gutters — **363 in 320**, with the More button ending
27px past the edge. So an *action* was clipped, which is the exact
defect #69 exists to prevent.
What yields is the **count**, last, after everything else. It is the
only item on that row that is neither an identity (the title, which the
navigation repeats) nor an action (the sort control and the buttons,
each the only place they are said). With it gone the header is 304 in
304 and the title even comes back to 19px.
Two things worth keeping:
- **The failure was found by the suite, not by the spec.** `make
ui-test` (964), `tsc` in both packages, `make lint`, `make test` and
the new `phone-search.spec.ts` were all green; what failed was
`header-action-overflow.spec.ts` at 320×600, which has nothing to do
with search. That is #62's lesson holding for a second change in a
row: anything that adds to or reflows the shell has a blast radius
the spec you wrote cannot see.
- **A collapsed thing has to still be in the DOM.** Returning `nothing`
from `renderCount()` would have taken the count away for the rest of
the session the first time a 320px window appeared, because
`measureFit` starts every pass from all-visible and needs a node to
un-hide. Same shape as the action buttons, which is where the pattern
was already written down.
## The e2e app is long-lived, so a staged job outlives the spec that staged it (measured 2026-08-21)
`make dev-headless` runs one app across every `make e2e` invocation, and
`/__test/emit` writes to a store that nothing clears. A first draft of
`phone-search.spec.ts` asserted the content starts at y=0 with the top
bar gone; it passed alone and failed in a suite run, because
`top-bar-fit.spec.ts` had staged a long-titled scan and `<job-band>` is
a real grid row whenever work is in flight.
The fix is not `beforeEach` cleanup — it is measuring the right thing:
the content starts where the **row above it** ends, which is true with a
job running and without one. An assertion against an absolute
coordinate was quietly also asserting "and no background job exists",
which is not something that spec is about or can arrange.