docs(android): the identity is read back, not declared twice
CI / check (push) Skipped
CI / e2e (push) Skipped
CI / check (pull_request) Successful in 2m32s
CI / e2e (pull_request) Successful in 8m22s

android-tier.md carried a warning block telling the reader not to use
run:device or deploy-device, and offered a manual sequence instead.
Both are wrong now: the tasks are the way in, and the warning would
read as a live hazard. It becomes a note about what changed, and the
manual sequence stays as the smallest thing that works when you want no
script between you and adb.

"The identity is declared twice" was the section this file had carried
for five phases saying nothing enforced that the two ids agree. It
describes the enforcement now, plus what APP_ID means since it stopped
being a setting it never was.

NOTES.md takes the four measurements: that the uninstall existed only
to cover a missing -r (which is what makes deleting it a fix rather
than a trade), that the emulator tasks installed on a phone, what
reading the id back costs, and the boot-wait race filed as #162.
This commit is contained in:
2026-08-20 14:35:16 -04:00
parent 4b392cb4c4
commit 998ce75fb6
2 changed files with 169 additions and 24 deletions
@@ -258,20 +258,25 @@ one.
`build/android/Taskfile.yml` ships more than the Makefile wraps, and
they are the right thing to reach for when you want something one-off:
> **Do not run `android:run:device` or `android:deploy-device`
> against a device that has the released app on it (#159).** Both begin
> with `adb uninstall {{.APP_ID}}`, and `APP_ID` defaults to
> `app.yellowjacket` — the **release** id — while `run:device` builds
> the **debug** variant, whose id is `app.yellowjacket.dev`. So it
> uninstalls the user's app, taking the library with it, installs a
> different package, and then fails to launch the one it removed. This
> is "the identity is declared twice" (below) cashing out. The safe
> sequence is at the end of this section.
> **These four were unsafe until #159 and are now the way in.** All of
> them began with `adb uninstall {{.APP_ID}}`, where `APP_ID` defaulted
> to `app.yellowjacket` — the **release** id — while `run` and
> `run:device` build the **debug** variant, whose id is
> `app.yellowjacket.dev`. So they uninstalled the user's app, taking
> the library with it, installed a different package, and then failed
> to launch the one they had removed.
>
> They share `scripts/android-deploy.sh` now, which **never**
> uninstalls (`install -r`, and a changed signing certificate is
> reported with the command rather than acted on), reads the package id
> back out of the built APK, and refuses a target that is not the kind
> the task names. There is nothing left to avoid; the manual sequence
> below is kept because it is still the smallest thing that works.
```
wails3 task android:run # debug build + emulator install + launch
wails3 task android:run:device # UNSAFE, see #159
wails3 task android:deploy-device # UNSAFE, see #159
wails3 task android:run:device # debug build + install + launch on a phone
wails3 task android:deploy-device # release build, same
wails3 task android:bundle:fat # AAB, for a Play Store upload
wails3 task android:studio # open build/android/ in Android Studio
wails3 task android:device:list
@@ -279,6 +284,16 @@ wails3 task android:logs:all
wails3 task android:clean
```
**`run` and `deploy-emulator` mean the emulator, and now say so to
adb.** They used a bare `adb install`, which with exactly one device
attached picks that device whatever it is — so with a phone plugged in
and no emulator running, the task whose summary reads "in the Android
Emulator" installed on the phone. They pass `--target emulator` and
refuse with `make android-emulator` as the remedy.
**`DEVICE_ID=<serial>` still names a device, and several attached
devices is now an error rather than a silent pick of the first.**
Two are deliberately **not** wrapped. `android:logs` greps logcat for
`(Wails|yellowjacket)`, which catches the `WailsBridge` tag but misses
the app's own process tag (`app.yellowjacket` — lowercase, so `Wails`
@@ -288,16 +303,51 @@ instead. And `ensure-emulator` boots whatever `-list-avds | tail -1`
returns, with no pidfile and no boot wait, so it cannot be stopped or
sequenced.
## The identity is declared twice
## The identity is read back from the APK
It used to be **declared twice**, and that is what #159 was.
`applicationId` in `build/android/app/build.gradle` is what Gradle
installs. `APP_ID` in `build/android/Taskfile.yml` is what every
adb-driven task uninstalls, launches and filters. **Nothing enforces
that they agree**, and `ANDROID.md`'s advice to set `APP_ID` in
`build/config.yml` does not work in beta.8 — `wails3 task` never reads
that file (verified with `--dry`), and even when set it feeds only the
adb commands, never Gradle. Change both or the official `run`/`deploy`
tasks address a package that is not installed.
installs; `APP_ID` in `build/android/Taskfile.yml` was what every
adb-driven task uninstalled, launched and filtered, and nothing
enforced that they agree. They did not: the debug buildType carries
`applicationIdSuffix ".dev"`, so every task that assembles a debug APK
addressed the release id. This file flagged the hazard for five phases
and it cashed out twice — once as a wrong `am start`, once as an
uninstall of the user's library.
**`scripts/android-pkgid.sh` is the one answer now.** It prints the
package id an APK declares (`aapt2 dump packagename`, falling back to
`aapt dump badging`), and the deploy path installs and launches *that*.
The APK is the authority because the task that installs it has just
built it: whatever Gradle resolved the applicationId to, suffixes and
flavours included, is in the file, and no default can disagree with it.
An APK it cannot read is a hard failure, never a fallback to a written
down default — guessing is the bug.
**`APP_ID` survives as an assertion, not a setting**, and has no
default. `wails3 task android:run APP_ID=app.yellowjacket` says "this
build had better declare that id" and is refused, naming both, *before*
anything is installed or a device is even chosen. It could never have
been a setting: `ANDROID.md`'s advice to put it in `build/config.yml`
does not work in beta.8 — `wails3 task` never reads that file (verified
with `--dry`) — and even when set it fed only the adb commands, never
Gradle.
`scripts/android-emulator.sh` derives `PKG` the same way, from
`bin/yellowjacket.apk` when one is built, so `make android-install`,
`android-launch`, `android-logs` and `android-smoke` follow whichever
variant is actually in `bin/`. `YJ_ANDROID_PKG` still overrides, and
the old literal survives only for a tree with no APK built yet.
**The uninstall is gone and is not coming back.** It existed to make
the bare `install` on the next line work at all — without `-r` Android
refuses an install over an existing package — so `install -r` removes
the *reason* for it rather than merely removing it. What is left is the
one case an uninstall really is the remedy, a changed signing
certificate, and that is exactly the case where performing it silently
costs the user their library. So it is named and not done, which is the
answer `scripts/android-emulator.sh` had already reached for
`make android-install`.
Related, and it will bite once: the launcher activity is
`com.wails.app.MainActivity` and the applicationId is
@@ -306,8 +356,10 @@ resolves the leading dot against the *applicationId* and fails with a
class-not-found that reads like a broken build. Always the
fully-qualified form.
**The safe way to put a debug build on a real device**, which is what
#52 used and what #159 exists to make unnecessary:
**`wails3 task android:run:device` is the way to put a debug build on a
real device**, since #159. What #52 used, before it was safe, was the
longer form, and it is still the smallest thing that works if you want
no script between you and adb:
```bash
wails3 task android:build ARCH=arm64 && wails3 task android:assemble:apk
@@ -315,9 +367,15 @@ adb install -r bin/yellowjacket.apk # -r, never uninstall
adb shell am start -n app.yellowjacket.dev/com.wails.app.MainActivity
```
`YJ_ANDROID_PKG=app.yellowjacket.dev` points `scripts/android-emulator.sh`
— and therefore `make android-smoke`, `android-logs`, `android-launch`
— at the debug id, which is otherwise `app.yellowjacket`.
The id in that last line is the one thing to keep an eye on by hand —
`./scripts/android-pkgid.sh bin/yellowjacket.apk` is what the tasks ask,
and it is a good habit before any `am start` written out in full.
`YJ_ANDROID_PKG=app.yellowjacket.dev` still overrides what
`scripts/android-emulator.sh` — and therefore `make android-smoke`,
`android-logs`, `android-launch` — addresses, but it is rarely needed
now: that default is read from `bin/yellowjacket.apk`, so it already
follows whichever variant was built last.
## What only a device can answer